Return to Home Page of Big Sky Fishing.Com

Montana Movies
The Horse Whisperer

Home > Books & Gifts > Montana Movies > The Horse Whisperer Newsletter | Photo Gallery | Search

The Horse Whisperer : Review

Search Now:
In Association with Amazon.com

The Horse Whisperer, the first novel written by Nicholas Evans, is a classic modern western. The film, directed by and starring Robert Redord, is also an excellent movie, if a bit slow at times. But for anyone who likes horses, enjoys beautiful photography of Montana and seeing Robert Redford, the Horse Whisperer is an excellent movie to see.

The Horse Whisperer Movie has a different ending than the book, so keep that in mind - although most people think the ending of the movie is better than in the Horse Whisperer book. The Horse Whisperer movie is also rather lengty, running 2 hours and 45 minutes. And while there are some slower spots, the quality of the movie, the subtle story, beautiful photography and excellent acting make the Horse Whisperer a movie well worth seeing.

The Horse Whisperer on DVD
The Horse Whisperer on VHS
The Horse Whisperer: Original Score Soundtrack
The Horse Whisperer : A Novel - Softcover Edition

Amazon Customer Review #1

Relaxing, warm romantic experience, uplifting and inspiring

The Horse Whisperer on DVD
The Horse Whisperer on DVD


I happened to watch this movie on a "snow day" when I was "iced-in" and ended up watching it 4 times! Redford shows himself as a class act once again in this relaxed, 'take your time' dramatic slash romantic film contrasting the fast big city life of a magazine editor (Kristen Scott Thomas)with the relaxed atmosphere on the Montana ranch of the "Horse Whisperer" (Robert Redford) whose therapeutic skills are sought out for a horse badly traumatized in an accident involving the editor's daughter. The "down home" atmosphere of the rancher's family and the unselfish, very caring approach of Redford's character provides treatment not only for the ailing horse but also for the daughter (not to mention the members of the viewing audience!!). I found this movie extremely refreshing with much room for personal reflection. A must for any truly passionate film aficianado.

Amazon Customer Review #2

Three hours about a horse?

The Horse Whisperer - A Novel
The Horse Whisperer - Softcover Edition


Well, not quite. When one thinks about it, it's about hope, redemption and the saving of souls. It's about a family who's been torn apart through a grizzly accident, leaving one teenage girl dead, and another teenage girl and her prized horse mangled (both physically and mentally). It's about a family's thinly veiled serenity being suddenly unmasked, and in the wake exposes a great vulnerability that lets loose the undercurrent of depression, frustration and hostility.

Annie (Kristin Thomas), a head-strong, high-pressure magazine editor and world traveler is suddenly (and maybe for the first time) faced with something she is totally unprepared to handle--losing her daughter. Seeing the ever widening gulf, she becomes desperate enough to leave New York and seek help from an unusual animal healer, Tom Booker (Robert Redford), a so-called horse whisperer. Throwing caution to the wind, and against her husband's wishes (nicely played by Sam Neil), Annie forces Grace (her daughter) to accompany her and Pilgrim (Grace's horse) to a small ranch in the vastly open and rugged state of Montana.

This is where the pace of the movie suddenly changes from the beehive of "civilization" to one of sedate morning dew, deep blue skies, rugged mountain sunsets, and the home-spun reality of a rancher's way of life. Booker, who quickly realizes that he has much more than just a horse to heal, reluctantly takes on the chore. What follows is a deliberately paced process of healing.

Although this laid-back movie may not be to everyones' taste (or patience), it worked its magic on me. Between 1 and 10, I give "The Horse Whisperer" an 8. It's a shame we don't see more of Robert Redford, either behind the scenes as a director, or in front of the camera.


Amazon Customer Review #3

Great Acting, Sensational Scenery and a Worthy story

Horse Whisperer Soundtrack
The Horse Whisperer: Original Score Soundtrack


Almost from the first scene there is enormous tension in this movie. The smashed innocence of youth, the imperious maneuvering of an overbearing mother/executive - executive/mother, and the seemingly willing doormat of a husband are all played against the shadow of a horribly injured horse, which for a time are the only wounds the players really acknowledge. It's easy to get involved in the plight of Pilgrim, the horse, but as the story progresses, it becomes clear that the horse's injuries are small potatoes compared to the injuries shouldered and nurtured by Scott Thomas (the mother) and her daughter - as well as Redford (the Whisperer), although I didn't piece that together until I'd watched it a second time.

Redford and Scott Thomas are at the top of their game (I'm not much of a Redford fan and Scott Thomas is new to me), and although Horse Whisperer subtly leads the viewer astray for a time, deliberately focusing on the injuries to the horse and the daughter, about 45min in to the movie you can sense real intrigue developing between Redford and Scott Thomas. Redford plays the strong, semi-silent Marlboro man (masking his own injuries behind a thick veneer of quiet competence), and Scott Thomas transports her restless world of conference-calls, cell phones, fax machines and overworked anxiety to the Big Sky meadows of Montana. It takes days, weeks, for her to recognize the incongruity; however, eventually the recognizes the quiet value hidden in ranch life, and when she does, Scott Thomas sheds her urban values in a rush - for a time.

I've enjoyed this movie several times - one of the few times I agree with the professional critics. Super! A must watch. Not really a "feel good" movie, but Horse Whisperer is a thoughtful "reality check" that leaves the viewer (or at least me), playing all sorts of woulda, coulda, shoulda mind games.


The Horse Whisperer on DVD
The Horse Whisperer on VHS
The Horse Whisperer: Original Score Soundtrack
The Horse Whisperer : A Novel - Softcover Edition


Top of Page
 


Montana Web Cams | Montana Information | Fly Fishing Gear | Fishing Boats | Site Map | About | Contact Us | FAQ | Advertising Information | List Your Business | Web Design Services | Advertiser Index | Privacy Policy
Return to Home of Big Sky Fishing.Com Fishing the Rivers in Montana Fishing the Lakes in Montana Fishing the Mountains in Montana Fishing & Hiking in Montana National Parks Books & Gifts Fly Fishing & Outdoor Gear The Art Gallery at Big Sky Fishing.Com Visit our Community Forum